_extract_from_forwarded_header() (guard_core/utils.py:172-181 in 3.12.0; :179 on master 08780f1) returns the selected X-Forwarded-For entry without any ipaddress validation. When that entry is attacker-controlled, an arbitrary string becomes client_ip and flows into BehaviorTracker (guard_core/handlers/behavior_handler.py:83-102), which interpolates it verbatim into both a Redis key name and a KEYS glob pattern:
key = f"behavior:usage:{endpoint_id}:{client_ip}"
await self.redis_handler.set_key("behavior_usage", f"{key}:{current_time}", "1", ttl=rule.window)
pattern = f"behavior_usage:{key}:*"
keys = await self.redis_handler.keys(pattern) # blocking KEYS, O(N) over keyspace
Same shape in track_return_pattern() (behavior_handler.py:135-142). redis_handler.keys() maps to the blocking Redis KEYS command (guard_core/handlers/redis_handler.py:265-275).
Three consequences, in increasing severity:
X-Forwarded-For: * makes the glob match every client's behavior-usage keys for the endpoint. Verified with a fake-Redis harness: a client 9.9.9.9 hit an endpoint 3 times (threshold=3 rule), then a single attacker request carrying XFF: * issued the pattern behavior_usage:behavior:usage:app.login:*:*, counted the victim's events, and tripped the rule on its first request. An embedded : also shifts which key segment is parsed as the timestamp (behavior_handler.py:94-100).f"{key}:{current_time}") and then issues a blocking KEYS scan whose cost grows with total keys — on the shared Redis instance, degrading every guard-core instance using it. Rotating arbitrary XFF strings multiplies distinct keys without bound.ban action passes the non-IP string to ip_ban_manager.ban_ip(), whose ipaddress validation raises ValueError uncaught in the behavioral processor — the request 500s.import asyncio
from types import SimpleNamespace
from guard_core.models import SecurityConfig
from guard_core.utils import extract_client_ip
class CIHeaders(dict):
def get(self, key, default=None):
for k, v in self.items():
if k.lower() == key.lower():
return v
return default
class FakeRequest:
def __init__(self, xff):
self.state = SimpleNamespace()
self.client_host = "10.0.0.1" # the TRUSTED proxy
self.headers = CIHeaders({"X-Forwarded-For": xff})
async def main():
config = SecurityConfig(trusted_proxies=("10.0.0.1",), enable_redis=False)
ip = await extract_client_ip(FakeRequest("*"), config)
print(repr(ip)) # -> '*' (arbitrary string, no validation)
asyncio.run(main())
Then BehaviorTracker.track_endpoint_usage("app.login", "*", rule) issues KEYS behavior_usage:behavior:usage:app.login:*:* — matching other clients' keys (full fake-Redis script: poc_xff_redis.py, available on request).
Integrity and availability of the behavioral-analytics subsystem and the shared Redis instance, in deployments where the extracted XFF position is attacker-controllable. No data exposure; not reachable with default settings (trusted_proxies defaults empty).
Fix: validate the extracted XFF entry with ipaddress.ip_address() before returning it from extract_client_ip() (fall back to the connecting IP on failure); escape glob metacharacters (*?[]) in anything interpolated into a KEYS pattern — or replace the KEYS+per-request-key design with an atomic counter / Lua sliding window (the rate-limit Lua script already shows the right shape).
{
"cwe_ids": [
"CWE-20"
],
"github_reviewed": true,
"github_reviewed_at": "2026-11-19T22:50:33Z",
"nvd_published_at": "2026-11-16T20:19:01Z",
"severity": "MODERATE"
}