GHSA-xp3q-r38w-vgqm

Relationship to GHSA-hgfg-j9pg-43xw

That advisory concerned the administrator's live UI layout, and commit 63c7d5474 resolved it by removing FilterUILayoutByPublishIgnore and nulling Conf.UILayout for readers. That fix is correct and complete for the live layout.

This report concerns a different endpoint, a different filter function and a different storage backing. /api/storage/getLocalStorage reads data/storage/local.json rather than Conf.UILayout, and its filter FilterLocalStorageByPublishAccess was not touched by that commit. The consequence is that the same serialized tab objects the earlier fix withheld continue to be served, from the closed-tab history rather than the live layout.

Summary

Three routes, /api/storage/getLocalStorage, getLocalStorageVal and getLocalStorageVals, are registered with CheckAuth only and are reachable by the publish RoleReader token and anonymously when Publish.Auth.Enable is false. All three call model.GetLocalStorage() and then, for read-only roles, FilterLocalStorageByPublishAccess.

That filter begins by assigning the administrator's entire storage map to its return value and then removes three specific fields. Everything else in the map is returned unmodified. A single unauthenticated POST with an empty body returns the administrator's recently closed tabs with their document titles and identifiers, their current search keywords and the paths those searches cover, the expanded private paths in their file tree, and per-document identifiers from several other keys.

Details

Routes. kernel/api/router.go:87-89 on master, the same block on the development branch:

ginServer.Handle("POST", "/api/storage/getLocalStorage",     model.CheckAuth, getLocalStorage)
ginServer.Handle("POST", "/api/storage/getLocalStorageVal",  model.CheckAuth, getLocalStorageVal)
ginServer.Handle("POST", "/api/storage/getLocalStorageVals", model.CheckAuth, getLocalStorageVals)

No CheckAdminRole, no CheckReadonly.

The filter is an allowlist inverted into a blocklist. kernel/model/publish_access.go:911 on master and :1481 on the development branch, byte-identical on both:

func FilterLocalStorageByPublishAccess(publishAccess PublishAccess, localStorage map[string]any) (ret map[string]any) {
    ret = localStorage            // the entire administrator map
    publishIgnore := GetInvisiblePublishAccess(publishAccess)
    // clears local-searchkeys["keys"]
    // clears local-searchasset["k"] and ["keys"]
    // blanks local-docinfo["id"], only when bt != nil, visible tier only, no password check
    return
}

local.json holds roughly thirty keys. Three are sanitized. The rest are returned as stored.

What survives. Taking the client's own list of keys it round-trips through this endpoint (app/src/protyle/util/compatibility.ts:563), the notable survivors are:

• local-closed-tabs. Up to SIZE_UNDO entries, each produced by layoutToJSON(item, tabJSON) at app/src/layout/Wnd.ts:779. This is the same serializer that produced the data in the earlier advisory: tab title, docIcon, rootId, notebookId, blockId, mode, action, and for a Search tab the entire config object. Unfiltered.
• local-searchdata. The live document-search configuration, including k (the search text), r (replace text), hPath, idPath (the paths the search was scoped to) and types. Note the filter clears the search history array and the asset-search keyword, but leaves the document-search keyword itself. The project's own standard is applied to two of the three related fields.
• local-filespaths. IFilesPath[] of {notebookId, openPaths[]}, the expanded private notebook and folder paths in the file-tree dock.
• local-fileposition, local-outline, local-zoom. Keyed by document or block identifier, so each discloses private document identifiers.
• local-move-path. {keys[], k}, the move-document dialog's path history and last keyword.
• local-recent-docs, local-history, local-flashcard, local-dailynoteid, local-layouts.

The asymmetry is visible in the function signature. In the same file, kernel/api/storage.go:

The two sibling filters take the request context and can therefore call CheckPublishAuthCookie to evaluate the password tier. FilterLocalStorageByPublishAccess does not receive the context, so it cannot perform that check at all. The visible-only limitation is fixed in the parameter list rather than in the body.

Separately, local-recent-docs passes through this endpoint unfiltered, which bypasses the dedicated FilterRecentDocsByPublishAccess that guards the same data on getRecentDocs.

Note on a prior assessment. getLocalStorage appears on lists of endpoints considered correctly filtered, on the basis that it calls a Filter*ByPublishAccess function. That observation is accurate and this report does not contradict it. The filter is called. What it does is assign the whole map and remove three fields.

No persistence side effect. The in-place mutations the filter performs do not corrupt the administrator's stored state, because GetLocalStorage re-reads and unmarshals storage/local.json on each call (kernel/model/storage.go:82), so the map is per-request. This is noted to pre-empt the concern rather than as part of the finding.

Proof of Concept

Precondition: publish mode enabled (default port 6808), anonymous when Publish.Auth.Enable is false, otherwise any publish reader account. An administrator who has used the client normally, closing some document tabs and running a search.

POST http://127.0.0.1:6808/api/storage/getLocalStorage
{}

→ 200. The returned map includes, among others:
     local-closed-tabs   entries carrying title, docIcon, rootId, notebookId,
                         blockId for recently closed documents, including
                         documents the reader has no publish access to
     local-searchdata    k, r, hPath, idPath for the administrator's current
                         document search
     local-filespaths    notebookId and openPaths for expanded private folders
     local-fileposition  keys are private document identifiers

getLocalStorageVal returns any single key by name, so a caller who only wants the closed-tab history can request it directly.

For contrast, requesting the same underlying data through the sibling endpoint shows the filtering that is applied elsewhere:

POST http://127.0.0.1:6808/api/storage/getRecentDocs
{}

→ 200, filtered by FilterRecentDocsByPublishAccess

while local-recent-docs inside the storage response is not.

Impact

An anonymous reader in publish mode, or any publish RoleReader, obtains the administrator's working context: the titles and identifiers of documents they recently had open, what they have been searching for and where, which private folders they have expanded, and per-document identifiers across several other keys. Titles and search keywords are author-written text and routinely describe the subject of the documents they refer to.

The document and notebook identifiers disclosed here are also the input required by identifier-to-path and path-to-content resolution, so the value is not limited to the metadata itself.

No document bodies are returned, and nothing is written. Confidentiality only.

Suggested fix

Invert the filter into an actual allowlist. Return only the keys a publish reader needs to render published content, which is a short list along the lines of local-images, local-emojis, local-pdftheme, local-fontstyles and the theme and zoom preferences, and drop everything else by default. New keys added in future then default to withheld rather than exposed.

Additionally, pass *gin.Context into FilterLocalStorageByPublishAccess so that any retained per-document entry can be gated with the full CheckBlockIdAccessableByPublishAccess including the password tier, matching the sibling filters in the same file.